In a recent blog post which has stirred the crypto community, Casey Rodarmor, creator of the Ordinals protocol, has confronted ideological Bitcoin maximalists for their stance on inscriptions and the censorship of transactions within the Bitcoin blockchain. This piece explores Rodarmor’s critique, his vision for the future, and broader discussions surrounding Ordinals.
So, what are Ordinals? In a nutshell, the groundbreaking Ordinals protocol allows for the embedding of various media, such as text, images, and videos, directly onto the Bitcoin blockchain. The protocol has not only introduced new possibilities, but sparked intense debates within the community.
Rodarmor’s critique, outlined in the blog post, challenges the prevailing sentiment among Bitcoin maximalists who view inscriptions as a threat to the blockchain’s core principles. He contends that the resistance amounts to “whining” and makes Bitcoin maximalists appear “weak.” In his words, the simultaneous belief that Bitcoin is “unstoppable internet money” while opposing the use of ordinals is a contradiction.
One of the primary points of contention revolves around the categorisation of inscriptions as spam, with some community members even discussing the possibility of a hard fork to address the perceived issue. Rodarmor dismisses this approach, suggesting that ignoring inscriptions and letting the market regulate their value is the most pragmatic solution. He predicts that the market will naturally price out less valuable inscriptions as more use cases compete for Bitcoin block space.
Rodarmor’s vision for the future of Bitcoin aligns with the concept that high fees are inevitable and should be embraced rather than resisted. He asserts that while there will always be high-value inscriptions, they won’t seriously compete with the utility of Bitcoin as a store of value and a medium for uncensorable transactions.
The rise of the Ordinals protocol has catalysed broader discussions about Bitcoin inscriptions, a phenomenon that gained significant attention in 2023. This innovative approach allows for the embedding of unique data directly into the blockchain, creating non-fungible tokens (NFTs) that encompass text, images, and videos. The concept has extended beyond Bitcoin, finding its way onto Ethereum and other Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM)-based chains like Solana and Avalanche.
The appeal of Bitcoin inscriptions lies in their potential to democratize access to low-cap crypto assets. In contrast to traditional fundraising methods dominated by venture capitalists and institutions, inscriptions provide a transparent and open-access distribution mechanism. This shift levels the playing field, empowering individual investors and underscoring the crypto industry’s commitment to inclusivity.
However, the surge in inscription activity has also raised concerns about the performance of blockchain networks. Testing the limits of various public chains, inscription-related activity has led to congestion and outages. Forbes cites examples including Celestia’s CIAS project, which experienced a massive influx of users causing network disruptions, and Arbitrum’s downtime on December 15 when the network stopped at 10:29 am ET due to a user surge from inscription protocols, causing network downtime for 78 minutes.
These incidents underscore the need for improved performance in mainstream public chains to handle potential future surges in user activity. The inscription phenomenon, while posing challenges, serves as a valuable test for blockchain networks, providing reference data for developers and users aiming for widespread adoption of applications.
The debate around Bitcoin inscriptions, fuelled by the likes of Casey Rodarmor, highlights the industry’s ongoing struggle to balance innovation with the preservation of core principles. The outcome of these deliberations is likely to significantly influence the future course of blockchain technology and its widespread acceptance.
Stay informed with our Bi-Weekly Pulse for the latest crypto and blockchain news.
Get access to the week’s most interesting reads, stats and find out about the most recent trends in the cryptocurrency market.