The PayPal Stablecoin: Potential for Success Amid Facebook’s Libra Setback

The PayPal Stablecoin: Potential for Success Amid Facebook’s Libra Setback

4 min read

The launch of the PayPal stablecoin, PayPal USD, this month marks a significant stride in the world of cryptocurrencies, signalling a departure from the past failures and a promising embrace of a more informed regulatory environment. In contrast to Facebook’s turbulent journey with its Libra project, PayPal’s stablecoin is primed for success due to the company’s well-established position in Washington and the evolving comprehension of stablecoin dynamics by policymakers over the last three years.

In a related development, the digital payments giant reported holdings of approximately $1 billion worth of cryptocurrencies on its balance sheet back in May 2023.


Policymaker Familiarity and Regulatory Landscape

PayPal’s decision to launch its PayPal stablecoin in the current climate reflects a transformed ecosystem where policymakers have gained a more comprehensive understanding of stablecoins. The introduction of federal stablecoin regulations has contributed to legitimising stablecoins in the eyes of lawmakers. In the words of Christopher Giancarlo, former chair of the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, “The world has changed dramatically since Facebook’s Libra project.” This transformation is rooted in the concerted efforts of the industry, including lobbying, to disseminate knowledge about stablecoins and their regulatory requirements.


Policy Environment: PayPal vs Facebook

Unlike Facebook’s Libra, which faced considerable opposition due to privacy concerns and political interference, PayPal is uniquely positioned as an established financial player with a significant presence in Washington. Records indicate that PayPal spent $1.13 million on federal lobbying last year, dedicating efforts to engage with cryptocurrency-related matters over several years. This distinction is pivotal as PayPal’s positioning on the financial side of the wall between banking and commerce is likely to alleviate concerns of lawmakers.


The Operational Framework

PayPal USD, unlike its ambitious counterpart Libra, is designed to be issued by Paxos Trust, a digital trust company. This stablecoin will be backed by U.S. dollar deposits and U.S. Treasuries, subject to the oversight of the New York State Department of Financial Services. While PayPal envisions the eventual use of its stablecoin for payments, its primary use is expected to be the facilitation of U.S. customers’ buying and selling of other crypto tokens on its platform.


Analysing Market Impact of the PayPal Stablecoin

Experts such as Dan Dolev, a senior analyst at Mizuho, see the PayPal stablecoin as a positive development, albeit not a game-changer for PayPal investors. The introduction of PayPal USD is perceived as a step in the right direction, offering a tangible example of innovation and expansion within the crypto landscape. However, the full extent of its impact on the market remains to be seen.


Learning from Libra’s Trajectory

Facebook’s Libra, while initially ambitious, encountered significant headwinds due to its far-reaching goals and the complexities surrounding its operations based in Switzerland and its pegging to a basket of currencies. The project sparked concerns over Facebook’s potential control over the financial system and user privacy. Regulatory confusion further hindered its progress, leading to a rebranding effort and an eventual shift of operations to the United States.


A Regulatory Shift

Critical to the evolution of the stablecoin landscape is the role of regulatory bodies. The U.S. Treasury, under the leadership of Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen, has acknowledged the need for a comprehensive regulatory framework for stablecoins. The Treasury’s assessment of stablecoins’ systemic risks and the consensus that prudential regulators should oversee them highlight the maturation of regulatory thought.


The Path Forward: PayPal and Stablecoin Potential

As demonstrated by PayPal’s cautious approach and alignment with regulatory frameworks, the company is poised to succeed where Facebook faltered. The shift in attitudes towards stablecoins, evidenced by the evolving stance of regulatory bodies like the Federal Reserve and the House Financial Services committee, paints a brighter future for stablecoin adoption and growth. The committee’s chair, Patrick McHenry, echoes this sentiment by urging swift action in passing legislation that empowers stablecoins to realise their full potential.

PayPal’s introduction of its stablecoin, PayPal USD, hence, represents a pivotal moment in the trajectory of stablecoins. The company’s strategic positioning, combined with the increased familiarity and understanding of stablecoin dynamics within the regulatory landscape, is a testament to its potential for success. By learning from the challenges faced by Facebook’s Libra project and aligning with evolving regulatory sentiments, PayPal’s move underscores the future potential and relevance of stablecoins in the ever-evolving landscape of digital finance.


Stay informed with our Bi-Weekly Pulse for the latest crypto and blockchain news.

Get access to the week’s most interesting reads, stats and find out about the most recent trends in the cryptocurrency market.