The United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has taken its regulatory efforts to a new level by filing lawsuits against two major cryptocurrency exchanges, Coinbase and Binance. This move marks a turning point for the industry as the SEC cracks down on crypto to establish its authority over a market that has largely operated outside traditional regulations.
The outcome of these lawsuits could have a transformative impact on the crypto market. If successful, they would effectively assert the SEC’s authority over cryptocurrencies. For years, the crypto community has argued that tokens are not securities and should not be subject to SEC oversight.
Kevin O’Brien, a former federal prosecutor and partner at Ford O’Brien Landy, highlighted the significance of these lawsuits. He noted that while the cases against Coinbase and Binance are separate, they both demonstrate the SEC’s increasingly aggressive campaign to regulate cryptocurrencies. The fact that the SEC has targeted such prominent players in the industry underscores the gravity of the situation.
The SEC’s complaint against Coinbase, filed in a Manhattan federal court, alleges that the platform has acted as a middleman in crypto transactions since at least 2019. The SEC claims that Coinbase failed to comply with disclosure requirements designed to protect investors while trading at least 13 crypto assets that should have been registered as securities. Notable tokens involved in the lawsuit include Solana, Cardano, and Polygon.
In response, Coinbase’s general counsel, Paul Grewal, stated that the company will continue its operations as usual and remain committed to compliance. However, market analysts, including Ed Moya from Oanda, believe that the SEC’s actions are just the beginning of a broader crackdown on crypto exchanges. Given that many exchanges offer tokens that operate on blockchain protocols targeted by regulators, the industry could face further regulatory challenges down the line.
Interestingly, the crackdown on crypto has had a paradoxical effect on Bitcoin, the leading cryptocurrency. Following news of the Binance lawsuit, Bitcoin initially experienced a significant drop to a three-month low. However, it quickly rebounded and surpassed the previous day’s high, highlighting how the SEC’s actions are driving some crypto traders back into Bitcoin.
The SEC’s pursuit of these lawsuits is rooted in its assertion that tokens should be classified as securities, a stance consistently advocated by SEC Chair Gary Gensler. Gensler has been steadily expanding the SEC’s authority over the crypto market, initially focusing on token sales and interest-bearing crypto products. Recently, the SEC has targeted unregistered crypto broker dealers, exchange trading, and clearing activities.
While a few crypto companies are licensed as alternative system trading systems, none currently operate as full-fledged stock exchanges. This year, the SEC has also sued Beaxy Digital and Bittrex Inc for failing to register as exchanges, clearing houses, and brokers.
Crypto companies, however, vehemently reject the notion that tokens meet the definition of securities. They argue that the SEC’s rules are ambiguous and that the regulatory body is overstepping its authority by attempting to regulate them. Nevertheless, many companies have already taken steps to enhance compliance, put products on hold, and expand their operations outside the United States in response to the regulatory crackdown.
Kristin Smith, CEO of the Blockchain Association trade group, strongly opposes Gensler’s efforts to oversee the industry and expresses confidence that the courts will prove him wrong. Nonetheless, these lawsuits have introduced uncertainty to the crypto market, prompting investors and companies to reassess their strategies.
Coinbase is one of the most prominent cryptocurrency platforms, serving millions of customers and managing substantial crypto assets. The SEC’s lawsuit against Coinbase seeks civil fines, the recovery of ill-gotten gains, and injunctive relief.
In addition to the Coinbase lawsuit, the SEC has accused Binance, one of the world’s largest crypto exchanges, of various violations, including inflating trading volumes, diverting customer funds, and misleading customers about its controls. Binance has vowed to vigorously defend itself against the lawsuit, dismissing it as a reflection of the SEC’s refusal to provide clarity to the crypto industry.
The lawsuits against Coinbase and Binance have already had consequences for these exchanges. In response to the legal action, customers have withdrawn significant amounts of funds from Binance and its US affiliate. The SEC has also moved to freeze assets belonging to Binance’s US affiliate.
The actions taken by the SEC aim to ensure compliance with securities laws and protect investors. While it introduces short-term uncertainty, some industry experts believe it will ultimately lead to a more stable and trustworthy crypto market, potentially attracting more institutional investors and fostering mainstream adoption of cryptocurrencies.
Whether or not crypto tokens are considered securities depends on various factors and can vary between jurisdictions. In many cases, cryptocurrencies and tokens are not automatically classified as securities, but certain types of tokens can indeed be classified as securities under certain circumstances.
In the US, the SEC uses the Howey Test to determine whether an asset qualifies as a security. The Howey Test considers whether an investment involves an investment of money in a common enterprise with an expectation of profits primarily from the efforts of others. If a token meets these criteria, it may be classified as a security and be subject to securities regulations.
Other jurisdictions have their own criteria and tests to determine if a token is considered a security. Some countries have issued guidelines or regulations specifically for cryptocurrencies and tokens, providing clarity on their classification and regulatory requirements.
To learn more about other important events occuring in the blockchain and crypto space, head to our news section.
Stay informed with our Bi-Weekly Pulse for the latest crypto and blockchain news.
Get access to the week’s most interesting reads, stats and find out about the most recent trends in the cryptocurrency market.